Erich Menzel
Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage

Reviews of Erich Menzel


Over the course of 45 years I have dealt with at least 10 to 15 realtors but Erich stands alone in my estimation. He was instrumental in helping us buy a house several years ago and surpassed our expectations in helping us sell a house recently. We have never encountered a more patient and knowledgeable person not just in real estate but in any professional setting. Erich doesn't just accept the standard, he sets it. I have recommended him to people in the past and will certainly continue to sing his praises in the future. Erich turns buying a house into buying a home.

-Logan W. Johnstown 2020

I would recommend Erich to anyone who is looking to hire a real estate specialist that is willing to go the extra mile for their client. Erich is honest, dependable, and incredibly hard working. His knowledge of sales etiquette and real estate are a huge advantage to his impressive skill set. Beyond that he is a great problem solver who is always able to address complex issues with strategy and confidence. Without a doubt, I confidently would recommend Erich as a dedicated, knowledgeable, all-around great person with undeniable talents and an absolute joy to work with!

-Mary K. Loveland/ Thornton 2020

Erich has done an incredible job on all of my now third purchase/sale of a home with him as an agent. He is very knowledgeable at what he does being able to handle issues that came up and was willing to go above and beyond to remedy any problems. I found the experience with him working as my realtor easy and stress free and was confident with him handling the process. Need to mention that my properties sold within days of going on the market also.

-Thom F. Fort Collins/Aurora 2020

Erich is friendly, hard-working, and professional. My husband and I have worked with him twice in the past five years and we were very pleased both times. Erich knows the real estate market in Colorado, and regardless of whether you're buying or selling, he will get the job done for you!

-Donna W. Johnstown 2020

Erich is a top notch realtor who connects well with clients as well as all the other real estate professionals involved in both selling and buying a home. Thank you, Erich!

-Adam P. Boulder 2019

I have bought and sold 5 properties in my life, and Erich is the best realtor I have had so far. Our property purchase was "small potatoes," but he went out of the way to help up in a land property line discrepancy. He responded quickly to our questions, and was a fantastic and patient realtor for a buyer who is an engineer . Big Kudos!

-Amanda K. Livermore 2019

I worked with Erich on the purchase of the house and was so pleased with his efforts that there was no question that I would use him when I decided to sell. Erich was very knowledgeable in suggesting improvements to the house that would help with the sale. He went above and beyond the usual realtor services in actually purchasing and installing some needed items, and even purchased bags of soil and spread them on the lawn. Erich also was very helpful in suggesting construction companies that provided a good product at a reasonable cost. This was my first experience in selling a house and Erich answered all my questions quickly. I would not hesitate to use Erich again to buy or sell real estate.

-Carl D. Fort Collins 2019

Erich is a great realtor to work with he returns phone calls promptly with knowledgeable answers. He has helped me through the buying and selling process I have recommended to friends in the past and would continue to do so.

-Susan G. Loveland 2019

I worked with Erich from CT to help get my dad's condo sold in Fort Collins, CO. It is a real challenge trying to sell a property from a distance but Erich was on top of every detail. He recommended local painters and rug cleaners and made sure they were given access to the condo. He kept me up to date via email and phone calls, was always positive and very knowledgeable about the market. When the condo was ready to be listed he suggested a listing price based on the market and the very day it was listed he got a cash offer for the full price! We needed to move quickly on the sale too as the proceeds were needed for my dad who is now in an assisted living facility. Erich was readily available by phone or email and extremely responsive! I wish I had another property to sell! I'd give it to him in a heartbeat! Thank you, Erich! This money will be a huge help and comfort to my dad!

-Erika D. Fort Collins 2019

I have known Erich Menzel for several years and have nothing but positive things to say about him. He brought professionalism and patience in the search for my home. He worked hard to determine me needs and exceeded my expectations. I was continually impressed with his responsiveness and helpful insights and impressive follow-through. Cheers to you Erich you're the best---

-Carol H. 2018

Erich was great. He got my home ready to sell and helped me move. He went above and beyond and it proved to be the difference in selling soon or waiting a while to move the property. Many thanks go to him for his work. The house sold before it even was listed.

-Ed R. Windsor 2017

I have worked with many brokers over the years, both residential and commercial. Erich is by far the most responsive and conscientious about following through and following up. He presented an excellent range of properties that allowed us to get a sense of the variety of properties available, and all within our price range. I would highly recommend Erich both as a seller's and a buyer's broker.

-Melody P. Red Feather Lakes 2017

I would recommend Erich over and above any Realtor in Colorado. His desire to find us the right house and then going above and beyond any other Realtor I have used or even heard of. He was ALWAYS there for us! He deserves 5 Stars plus!

-Jeannie J. Greeley 2017

We couldn't have asked for a better realtor than Erich. He is a true professional, but he is also very down-to-earth and fun to spend time with. Since we weren't sure what area we wanted to live in, Erich was more than willing to show us as many properties as we needed to see until we found the  perfect place. We would highly recommend Erich to anybody looking for the perfect place to call home.

-Steve G. Johnstown 2016

We contacted the listing agent because we were looking at a foreclosed property in Estes Park, Colorado. Erich immediately returned our call and was able to show us the home on very short notice. We had the privilege of working with him over the course of purchasing the home. He was very  responsive with providing necessary documents and returning phone calls. We have purchased several houses over the years, and we found him to be one of the best when it came to professionalism and patience. It was great working with Erich he was very familiar with the area and was able to provide valuable information regarding the home buying process for this particular area.

-Tyrone V. Estes Park 2016

While looking for a home in a very competitive market, Erich went the extra mile for us. Looking at our budget and our wants/needs, he was able to show us a number of options, including some we would not have expected. That turned out great since we closed on a house that was totally different than  what we started out looking for, and is so much better. Once we had an offer accepted, Erich walked us through the process to make the closing as quick and painless as possible. He is a true professional.

-Evan M. Erie 2016

Erich is patient and helpful. He worked around our schedules for showings. His insight on homes and knowledge of what areas and neighborhoods have the best resell, schools, shopping and outdoor activities. Erich took the time to understand what we wanted in a home and was able to match almost  all of our criteria without showing us homes out of our price range. We would recommend Erich to anyone!

-Megan B. Loveland 2016

Erich helped me purchase my first investment property. I was very picky on what I was looking for and he was very understanding of my situation and couldn't have been more patient. The guy even bought me a beer after looking at a property. I plan on purchasing another property in 2016 and  wouldn't even consider working with any other realtor. Erich is definitely my guy!

-Ben C. Milliken 2015